There Should Be a Checklist for Maps

Earlier this week, Stephanie Evergreen posted this great checklist for data visualizations. She and Ann Emery designed it to help social scientists understand the elements of a successful graph and offer guidance on how to make a graph better. I’ve seen the list tweeted by data viz experts like Alberto Cairo and had it forwarded […]
Stephanie Evergreen and Ann Emery
Click for full-res [pdf]. (Stephanie Evergreen and Ann Emery)

Earlier this week, Stephanie Evergreen posted this great checklist for data visualizations. She and Ann Emery designed it to help social scientists understand the elements of a successful graph and offer guidance on how to make a graph better.

I've seen the list tweeted by data viz experts like Alberto Cairo and had it forwarded it to me by a designer I used to work with. It got me thinking that a list like this for maps would be really useful. We're beginners at mapmaking here at Map Lab, and we'd love a list like this to check our own maps against, and to help us evaluate maps we come across.

I haven't found a map checklist yet, and when I asked if one existed on Twitter...

.@wiredmaps @albertocairo not yet but sounds like you just volunteered to make one :) Happy to post on my blog when you do.

— Stephanie Evergreen (@evalu8r) May 16, 2014

So, let's make a checklist!

Step 1: Experts tell us what should be on the list (please help!)

Tell us what you think should be on the list in the comments below

Update: At least one map checklist has been located:

@rsimmon @wiredmaps @evalu8r @albertocairo our effort here but needs a little update to better account for web maps: May 16, 2014

There is a lot on this list – would a more condensed/streamlined/basic list be possible... or useful?

Update: Another checklist has been found (Use the first link. The second link is the same list from above):

@wiredmaps @evalu8r @albertocairo @AnnKEmery @rsimmon here are a couple to start with: *

— Jean Haley (@eval_jean) May 20, 2014

Update: A new checklist has been created by Stamen!

our interactive map checklist: for @wiredmaps. #maplist what else goes on it? is a print map checklist different?

— Stamen Design (@stamen) May 21, 2014